By: Trisha Welstad on January 25, 2018
Historian, Dominic Erdozain’s, The Soul of Doubt: The Religious Roots of Unbelief from Luther to Marx focuses on the roots of secularism that arise from seeds of doubt within Christendom from the era of the Reformation and grow into the modern era. “The ‘religious roots’ that I consider fundamental to modern cultures of unbelief are…
By: Jean Ollis on January 25, 2018
I feel a little star struck. It was a joy to interact with the author himself, Dominic Erdozain, on our Cape Town advance. It’s even more intimidating to prepare for a synchronous discussion where I need to sound informed. Just as Dominic’s children pleaded after his time intensive writing efforts (“JUST PLAY WITH US!) I,…
By: Mark Petersen on January 25, 2018
Dominic Erdozain, in his remarkable book, The Soul of Doubt: The Religious Roots of Unbelief from Luther to Marx, takes conventional wisdom and flips it on its head. While most would claim that doubt is a child of secularity, finding its source in the abandonment of faith, Erdozain demonstrates that an outcome of the Reformation…
By: Mike on January 25, 2018
Dominic Erdozain’s The Soul of Doubt cuts a wide theological swath through the Reformation, Enlightenment, and into the Modernistic era of the 21st Century. He asks why was there so much religious violence when the command for Christians was to love one another. His hypothesis, drawing from a historical-religious analysis from Luther to Marx, concludes…
By: Stu Cocanougher on January 25, 2018
And if there’s life on other planets Then I’m sure that He must know And He’s been there once already And has died to save their souls (Unidentified Flying Object, Larry Norman, 1971) As a teen, growing up in the 1980s in Nashville, Tennessee, I was fascinated by the music of the Jesus…
By: Christal Jenkins Tanks on January 25, 2018
Smith, Taylor and Erdozain For the past few weeks the questions that have been explored are what does it mean to be secular? And what does it look like to live in a secular world? The exploration of secularization as it relates to our understanding of doubt, unbelief and the human condition have been heavily…
By: Jason Turbeville on January 25, 2018
“For some time now—at least since John Wesley’s work in the eighteenth century—sharp minds have noticed that an intensified religious consciousness may paradoxically stimulate secularization. Wesley as cited by Max Weber makes a poignant lament: the increase of religious virtue necessarily increases industry and frugality, which increases wealth, which may in turn diminish the appeal…
By: Dave Watermulder on January 25, 2018
A number of years ago after a Christmas Eve service at our church, a young man came up to talk with me. He had been raised in our congregation and was well remembered by those who had nurtured him in his faith as a youth. He was now living in New York City doing social…
By: Lynda Gittens on January 25, 2018
Reading these three books on Secularity can place the thought in one’s conscience to take a bath. How Christians considered themselves clean because they were washed by the blood of Jesus but misused God’s purpose by disregarding those not of the believers’ family as unclean. The Pharisee’s were known for their righteous ways. There…
By: Mary Walker on January 25, 2018
Modernity is a war of religious ideas, not a war on them.[1] In his fascinating book, The Soul of Doubt, Dominic Erdozain demonstrates that it is not science but conscience that has produced our modern culture of religious doubt. “The ‘religious roots’ that I consider fundamental to modern cultures of unbelief are twofold: the positive…
By: Jennifer Williamson on January 25, 2018
In The Soul of Doubt Erdozain contends that most of Christianity’s starkest critics (i.e. those who cried, “Foul!” when Calvin burned “heretics” at the stake and Luther thumbed his nose at morality) made arguments rooted in genuine Christian ethics. His essential claim is that “[T]he ‘secular’ critique of Christianity was a burning product of the…
By: Greg on January 25, 2018
“Buddha would have made a great Christian,”says Steve Cioccolanti, “because his life and teaching were not against any particular religion, rather searching for the ultimate truth and purpose of life.”[1] A Christian can see the hand of God move in the lives of those others have deemed secular. God can been seen throughout history moving…
By: Jake Dean-Hill on January 24, 2018
Dominic Erdozain’s book, The Soul of Doubt: The Religious Roots of Unbelief from Luther to Marx, was a fascinating and often times humorous read. The latter I did not expect from a book on this topic. A few things stood out to me as I read: The fact that the Christian’s conscience is highlighted as…
By: Katy Drage Lines on January 24, 2018
Everything has two faces.– Pierre Bayle Some of my favorite people claim no faith, or proudly reject any association with Christianity or the Church. And honestly, who can blame them, these days? For instance, a friend of mine grew up in the church, came out as gay, was rejected by that community and left the faith,…
By: Jay Forseth on January 24, 2018
While reading around the book before reading the book, The Soul of Doubt (thank you Adler for teaching us how to first read around a book), other titles from Dominic Erdozain caught my attention–Does Sport Build Character?, The Problem of Pleasure, In Praise of Folly, Religion and Recreation… Caught my attention, yes he did! After reading Erdozain…
By: Dan Kreiss on January 24, 2018
Much like last week’s text, the title of the work for this week seems oxymoronic. What part does theSoul have in doubt? For Dominic Erdozain, there is an historical connection between Christian naysayers and the core of the faith but, his premise suggests that genuine opposition is fertilized in the soil of Christianity. “His claim is that…
By: Jennifer Dean-Hill on January 24, 2018
My mother’s words still ring in my ears when describing the rowdy Spring breakers in my hometown of Palm Springs California, who were less than model citizens with their lawlessness and drunken street orgies: “They are very secular.” Even though the word lacked meaning to my young ears, I understood the inference from her derogatory…
By: Jim Sabella on January 23, 2018
I used to collect fossils. When I was pastoring in Pennsylvania I found this huge fossil—about the size of a basketball split in half. It looked like a sponge on one side and like a coiled snake on the other. I had never seen anything like it before. At the time we didn’t have the…
By: Christal Jenkins Tanks on January 19, 2018
For the past two weeks, I have pondered on what it means to be secular in America. In America, I have found that it is not a matter of if someone believes in God or has a spiritual belief system but a matter of what exactly they profess to believe in. I live in a…
By: Chip Stapleton on January 19, 2018
Ian, our seven year old, is somewhat obsessed with time. The first thing he does every morning – no matter how early it might be – is come in to our room, grab my cell phone and check the time (and the weather). If we are in the car, or at home there is never…
