DMINLGP

DMin, Leadership and Global Perspectives: Crafting Ministry in an Interconnected World

Adjusting to Change

Written by: on May 16, 2018

Change

As a therapist, the predominate diagnosis I treat with my clients is adjustment disorder, with or without anxiety, or depression. This disorder is due to an individual enduring a major life stressor, everything from a death of a pet to the loss of a family member, marriage, or job, and are experiencing a difficult time coping successfully with the changes. Managing change can be very stressful, and the responses to change vary. Some get angry, shut-down, depressed, sad, busy, compulsive, blaming, sick, distracted, addicted, ashamed, and anxious, and others seem to breeze through the change only to have the crises crop up years later. No one can escape the unavoidable positive and negative effects of change. Bridges introduced a 3 phase transition that can easily be used for relationships and organizations desiring to manage change: Letting Go, Neutral Zone, and New Beginning.[1]This clear and concrete process encompassed the framework of the book, Managing Transitions, and created an easy visual for some of the other points to build neatly on.

Here are some top highlights of managing transitions:

“Transition starts with an ending.”[2]We all want the new and fresh beginning but few of us consider what we have to say goodbye to until we are experiencing the change. Nostalgic memories creep in as we reminisce about “how things used to be” as we struggle to adapt to the new changes. Today I talked with a woman starting on her fourth marriage, and watched her hang her head as she expressed her desire to stay with her first husband who loved her deeply over 30 years ago. While the very next session, I helped a couple work at amicably ending their 15-year-old marriage wrecked with infidelity, mistrust, and irreconcilable pain. I wondered if they would regret their choice like this other woman as they attempted to overcome one of life’s most difficult losses, divorce. No transition can happen without an ending or loss to pave the way for new beginnings. Yet even though we know “beginnings depend on endings, the problem is, people don’t like endings.”[3]

“Treat the past with respect.”[4]I was reminded of a time my husband Jake, was a youth pastor and had collected many important files, program development and marketing materials, and contact information. When he was promoted to Administrative Pastor, he generously handed down a decade’s worth of collected youth program materials to the new youth pastor. Upon receiving them, he promptly walked over to the garbage and threw all the files away, stating he was going to do a new contemporary ministry so he didn’t need the old files. As the weeks went on, he would come to Jake and ask about previous event marketing materials, information on networking contacts, various program development, etc…and Jake would jokingly respond: “That was in the files.” We were all shocked at the lack of respect for the past and resistance to honor what had been previously developed with the thriving youth program. “Honor the past for what it has accomplished”[5]is a beautiful principle to live by and one that can make our lives more manageable with a transition. It is easy to think new is better, but this sets a dangerous stage for age discrimination as history truly is our best teacher.

“Purpose, Picture, Plan, and Part”[6]  are the 4 P’s suggested to foster new beginnings as they cannot be willed or forced and require strategic planning in order to be cultivated. If people do not understand the purposeof what they are doing, they have a difficult time developing teamwork. Similarly, people need to understand the bigger picture or the vision of what is being developed if they are going to get invested. A strategic plan is necessary for forward movement, and finally identifying each other’s part in creating a new story is essential to developing new beginnings. This process reminds me of my intake session for couples as I identify their purpose with therapy, have them describe a picture of their ideal relationship, develop treatment goals as we make a plan to facilitate change, and define the parts, roles and expectations of each of us involved.

“Choosing the path of renewal.”[7]What a powerful statement that empowers one to choose renewal as they embrace the process of recovering from change. This statement suggests one can choose and even foster renewal versus choosing a “slow death”[8]of stagnation. Even more empowering is asking the question, “‘What part of my identity—of the way I come across, and even the way I experience myself—do I need to let go of if we are going to enter the Path of Renewal?’”[9] This puts the responsibility and power on the person rather than blaming or waiting for others to change. Answering 3 questions that correlate with each stage of the 3 step change phase is a powerful strategy towards fostering renewal, first for yourself and then for the organization.

“1. What is it time for (me)/us to let go of?

  1. How will (I)/we spend time in the neutral zone?
  2. What is the new beginning going to require of (me)/us and others in the new organization, marriage?”[10](parenthesis mine).

In my own life, I want to choose the path of renewal and work with others to renew and rejuvenate what needs to be refreshed and remodeled in their lives. It is an honor and privilege to work with so many great people trying their best to navigate and manage transitions. We need each other to grapple with the stresses of change, and we need a God who cares for the heartaches change provokes and seeks to redeem every change our life encounters.

 

[1]William Bridges, Managing Transitions, 25th anniversary edition: Making the Most of Change,(Philadelphia: PA, Da Capo Press, 2016) 259, Kindle.

[2]Ibid., 309-310, Kindle.

[3]Ibid., 628-629, Kindle.

[4]Ibid., 884, Kindle.

[5]Ibid., 901, Kindle.

[6]Ibid., 1398-1399, Kindle.

[7]Ibid., 2018, Kindle.

[8]Robert E. Quinn, Deep Change: Discovering the Leader Within, (San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass, 1996), 135, Kindle.

[9]Ibid., 2033-2034, Kindle.

[10]Ibid., 2030-2045, Kindle.

 

About the Author

mm

Jennifer Dean-Hill

10 responses to “Adjusting to Change”

  1. Mary Walker says:

    Jen, I really looked forward to your post on this book. This is what you do for a ministry. You reiterated a lot of great things from the book, but the one that seems most difficult to me is, “Choosing the path of renewal.” How do you help people to WANT to choose the path to renewal? It is so heartbreaking when the person just wants to be selfish. The 3 powerful questions that you ask seem so be a good plan for those who do want to. Hopefully, if they came to see you they are ready!
    Great post and do you have anything on mid-life crisis?

    • mm Jennifer Dean-Hill says:

      Mary, my policy in working with people is I don’t take any mandatory clients, whether resistant youth or court-mandated clients. It is too hard to work against the will, not to mention, disrespectful. People change when they are ready and willing.

      Mid-life crises- hmmm that’s a good one. I deal a lot with people in this arena and the biggest task is to rediscover who they are. I created a 3 step process: clean, create, complete and call it a Relationship Remodel. It’s what I used for me and then put it into words and actions for others. Any materials that allow a person to rediscover, recreate, and remodel who they are, are great resources.

  2. Jim Sabella says:

    Another great post, Jenn. I always appreciate your insights. There are so many helpful things in this book. One in particular you highlighted, when facing change we need to choose the path of renewal. Change can make a person feel so out of control. It’s good to know that even in change a person has some control, maybe not over the change, but how they react to the change and also the path to renewal. I think that is where most of the growth takes place. Thanks, Jenn.

    • mm Jennifer Dean-Hill says:

      Thanks Jim – yes, I struggle to remember how much control I have when things feel so out of control. To stop the spinning and anxiety, I have to remember my control and how I want to react. To be honest, I don’t feel very successful at this but I will continue to practice. At least I have a plan. 🙂

  3. Stu Cocanougher says:

    Ouch! That story of the new youth minister throwing away the files really got to me. I think it is a great picture of what we all struggle with.

    As a youth minister for over 20 years, I often had seminary student interns who were apt to let others know that the could do a much better job than I did.

    Another memory, when I first came to Soutcliff so many years ago, I had a secretary who had a difficult time working for be because of how I did things differently. In retrospect, I probably had little patience with her because she questioned virtually every decision I made.

    Anyway, you are so right, healthy transitions honor the past, but still press on towards the future.

    • mm Jennifer Dean-Hill says:

      Yes Stu, I can relate to the arrogance of not building from the past. As I age, I find myself valuing history and past perspectives far more than I did in my 20’s or 30’s.

      I hear you with the secretary- people who constantly question me is hard as I am forward focused and stopping to answer their questions slows me down. They are my patience teachers.

  4. Lynda Gittens says:

    Jen, I would say this book’s subject fits your ministry. Your ability to work with various personalities and their situations, as well as, having to change your approach at times is the recipe for managing transitions.

    Great post

  5. Kristin Hamilton says:

    This is a great summary and application, Jen! I had to laugh even as I winced at the arrogance of that new youth pastor. So many times I thought I knew a better way, only to have to eat crow and ask for help from someone with a better knowledge of history.
    I love the way Bridges highlight respecting the past and planning for the future as a continuing cycle. We are constantly needing to let go of things, but that doesn’t have to mean shutting them out of our memories. It sounds like you do a deep and crucial work in helping people honor their memories, process their regrets, and prepare for a renewed future. I like that.

  6. mm Katy Drage Lines says:

    Jen, you did such a nice job of connecting the transition process and the need to choose a path of renewal into your own work; it’s just another affirmation of why what you do in your ministry is so important. Thanks for bearing witness to the imagination of ending and renewing well.

    Your story of Jake’s youth ministry was disappointing to hear. A disrespecting of the past will lead towards resentment from those who lived and built those experiences. We had a surprise birthday party for the church today to celebrate Pentecost and the birth of the church. During the party, we asked folks to share stories of the past, how they saw the Holy Spirit at work in individuals and the life of our church and other churches. What a fun way to remember and celebrate the past!

  7. Christal Jenkins Tanks says:

    Jen this is an amazing post! There were so many good gems in this blog post. I could honestly speak to each of them with real life examples. Transition must start with an end. This is so hard to initially grasp! Each story you shared provides greater evidence of how people process transition. Again great post!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *